Dan Fahrner: Why The Old Playbook No Longer Works
A great product and a spot on the shelf used to give beverage brands a fighting chance, but today’s consumers have more choices than ever. As drinking habits change and competition grows across categories, what does it really take for a beverage brand to stand out and keep customers coming back?
As the beverage market becomes more competitive, Dan Fahrner sees brand identity, flavor innovation, and consumer experiences as essential to standing out beyond price and availability. After relaunching Shake Up around its Indiana fairground roots, he found that digital marketing alone couldn’t drive growth, so his team embraced in-store samplings, local events, and community partnerships. His experience shows that getting a product onto shelves is only the beginning; lasting success comes from building genuine demand and giving customers a reason to buy again.
On this episode of the Firebelly Social Show, Duncan Alney talks with Dan Fahrner, CEO and Co-founder of Shake Up Cocktails, about adapting to a changing beverage industry. They discuss shifting drinking habits and the rise of RTDs, why distribution doesn’t guarantee demand, and how brand storytelling and grassroots marketing drive growth. Dan also shares what he would do differently if launching Shake Up today.
Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn:
- [1:51] Dan Fahrner on the changing beverage industry and shifting consumer drinking habits
- [5:28] How single-serve and variety packs are disrupting alcohol sales
- [8:02] The potential impact of tighter THC regulations on consumer drinking choices
- [11:52] What really defines an RTD, and why it’s confusing
- [19:47] Why distribution doesn’t guarantee demand or consumer loyalty
- [24:50] How Shake Up identifies and reaches its ideal “social flavor seeker” consumer
- [35:27] The essential playbook for scaling beverage brands
- [46:44] Dan busts the myth that “good liquid sells itself” in beverage today
About Dan Fahrner:
Dan Fahrner is the CEO and Co-founder of Shake Up Cocktails, an Indianapolis-based beverage brand crafting full-flavored canned cocktails with real ingredients. Under his leadership, Shake Up Cocktails has expanded regionally, built a loyal following, and become a case study in adapting to changing consumer tastes. With more than 15 years of experience in digital marketing and brand strategy, Dan combines brand storytelling and community engagement to connect with consumers and build demand.
Resources Mentioned in this episode
- Duncan Alney on LinkedIn
- Firebelly Marketing
- Dan Fahrner on LinkedIn
- Shake Up Cocktails
- Samuel Anderson on LinkedIn
- Hi & Mighty
- BevAssets
- “Hi And Mighty: Fueled By Nostalgia And Love” on the Firebelly Social Show
- “Samuel Anderson: Building A Community Matters” on the Firebelly Social Show
- Jungle Jim’s
- Surfside
- High Noon
- Super Lyte
- Outlaw Light Beer
- White Claw
- Total Wine
- Binny’s Beverage Depot
- Payless Liquors
- Dole Whip
Quotable Moments:
- “Distribution is not demand. I think that a lot of young brands, especially, learn that the hard way.”
- “What’s in the package is more important in order to get somebody to rebuy, for sure.”
- “The hardest part about scaling regionally or nationally is, you know, developing that velocity.”
- “The biggest thing I would do differently is I would focus on variety pack only.”
- “One selling point is certainly not enough. You gotta have it all.”
Action Steps:
- Understand your ideal consumer beyond demographics: Analyzing purchasing behaviors, social media insights, and customer preferences helps brands identify their target audience and create more meaningful experiences.
- Build demand beyond product distribution: Combining in-store samplings, local events, digital marketing, and community partnerships helps generate awareness, encourage trial, and drive repeat purchases.
- Strengthen your brand story and differentiation: Highlighting authentic brand origins, distinctive flavors, and unique experiences helps products stand out in crowded markets and build lasting customer connections.
- Adapt product offerings to changing consumer preferences: Embracing variety packs, single-serve formats, and emerging beverage categories allows brands to meet evolving demands and create new growth opportunities.
- Develop a localized strategy for market expansion: Partnering with committed distributors, investing in local brand ambassadors, and tailoring marketing efforts to regional preferences helps brands build sustainable sales momentum.
Powered by Rise25 Podcast Production Company